Module 6 Report ‘In Brief’ summary – Care Sector

Report and Recommendations In Brief

The UK Covid-19 Inquiry is an independent public inquiry examining the response to, and impact of, the Covid-19 pandemic to learn lessons for the future. Its terms of reference were set by the then Prime Minister Boris Johnson.

The scale of the pandemic was unprecedented; the Inquiry has a huge range of issues to cover. The Chair of the Inquiry, Baroness (Heather) Hallett DBE, decided to address this challenge by dividing its work into separate investigations known as modules. Each module focuses on a different topic with its own public hearings where the Chair heard evidence.

Following hearings, recommendations for change are developed and put into a Module Report. Each report contains findings from the evidence collected in that module and the Chair’s recommendations for the future. Reports for Modules 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 have already been published.

The sixth module examines the impact of the pandemic on the adult social care sector in England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.1 The module includes care provided in adult care and residential homes, in people’s own homes by professional carers and unpaid care provided by family members or friends. It looks at the decisions made by each nation’s government and considers:

  • what happened to people living and working in the care sector during the pandemic;
  • how limiting visits to care homes affected residents and their loved ones; and
  • how decisions to discharge patients to free up hospital beds affected those living and working in care homes.

The module also examines the steps taken in care homes to stop the virus spreading and the care sector’s capacity to respond to the pandemic.

Future reports will focus on the following areas:

  • Module 7 – Test, trace and isolate  
  • Module 8 – Children and young people  
  • Module 9 – The economic response to the pandemic 
  • Module 10 – The impact on society

Module 6: Care Sector

The Covid-19 pandemic had a devastating impact on the many millions of people across the  UK who receive adult social care. The impact was also damaging to the millions more who  provided that care, whether paid or unpaid. 

Protecting the adult social care sector as a whole appeared to be something of an  afterthought. The initial focus of all four governments of the UK was on protecting hospitals.  This came at the expense of people using and providing care services, despite the  vulnerability of recipients of care. There was no “protective ring” around care homes “right  from the start” of the pandemic, as claimed at the time and a continuing lack of significant  action taken to protect care homes across the UK lasted until mid April 2020.  

In care homes, there were over 43,000 recorded deaths involving Covid-19 between March  2020 and July 2022; Covid-19 was the second leading cause of death in care homes in all  four nations of the UK in 2020.

Key findings

  • The adult social care system is made up of many different parts. This meant that  government ministers could not easily see what was going on or control what happened.  The action taken by the UK government, Scottish Government, Welsh Government and  Northern Ireland Executive to try and protect workers and users of care came too late.
  • In March 2020, the four governments took the decision to speed up the discharge of  patients from hospitals to free up much-needed hospital beds. But the lack of available  tests meant that patients were discharged from hospital to care homes without knowing  whether they had Covid-19. 
  • At this stage, there was also no vaccine. To stop Covid-19 spreading in care homes, it  was important to keep people separate and isolate them from others when they  returned from hospital in case they had been infected. However, this was not initially  included in official guidance in March 2020 in England, Wales and Northern Ireland. This  was a significant oversight.
  • Guidance on preventing infection introduced at the beginning of the pandemic advised  care workers to avoid being within two metres of the person being cared for. This was  unrealistic – most social care involves close contact while helping with daily activities  such as washing, dressing and eating.
  • From mid-March 2020, care workers were advised to wear personal protective  equipment (PPE). However, there was a severe shortage of PPE supplies. This meant  that care workers had to work in either unsuitable or poor-quality PPE or with no PPE at  all. This was unacceptable.
  • Because visitors to care homes could have Covid-19 unknowingly and infect residents  and staff, visits were very limited. The strictness and length of limits on visits caused  enormous harm to residents and their loved ones, often resulting in a significant decline  in the health and wellbeing of residents.
  • Supporting care workers to stay away from their jobs if they were infected with Covid-19  was also a vital way to stop it spreading. Given their extremely important role, financial  support to protect care workers from losing wages needs to be in place at the start of  any pandemic. 
  • Routine in-person inspections of care settings stopped, pausing important checks on  the quality of care being provided to vulnerable residents.
  • During the pandemic, there were approximately 5.8 million unpaid carers across the UK.  Some support was made available to them during the pandemic but it came too late and  problems identifying unpaid carers made it difficult to deliver support.
  • In Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, registers of care workers meant that recently  retired care professionals could be easily identified and invited to return to work. These  registers also made it easier to communicate with the workers to signpost advice and  guidance. There is currently no workforce register in England.
  • Data gaps were a significant problem, particularly in the early months of the pandemic.  Differences in the way that data about deaths were collected and published meant that  real time data on the number of deaths in care homes in each nation were not available  until mid to late April 2020.
  • There was also a lack of data about the number of people receiving care in their own  homes who had died. The data that are available suggest that more people died at  home during the pandemic than before the pandemic. As healthcare professionals were  not always available to provide support, more end-of-life care had to be provided by  people who were untrained, including sometimes by family and friends, without the  necessary medication and without appropriate support.
  • The speed of the pandemic meant that sensitive discussions about advance care plans  (which record someone’s preferences for their future medical care in case they become  seriously ill) were often rushed or did not happen at all. Before the pandemic, UK health  and social care professionals were not required to have end-of-life training. Mandatory  end-of-life care training is needed. 
  • The Inquiry heard concerns about Do Not Attempt Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation  (DNACPR) decisions not being made appropriately or sensitively. A DNACPR is a  decision by medical staff not to attempt CPR. People can also state their own wishes  about this in advance. DNACPRs are person specific and should not be applied to  groups of people. Discussions about DNACPR must be handled sensitively and in a way  that suits each person.

Recommendations

The recommendations in this Report must be acted upon now before the next pandemic  strikes. In order to ensure that the UK’s adult social care sector is better protected and  equipped to respond to the next pandemic, the Inquiry recommends:

  • improving arrangements for pandemic planning to ensure clearer structures, roles  and responsibilities;
  • better planning for separating (isolating) care home residents with potential infections,  including those discharged from hospitals;
  • implementing financial support schemes that are ready to be rolled out to support  adult social care staff to self-isolate/limit staff movement;
  • publishing guidance on how limiting visiting will be decided upon in a future  pandemic; 
  • maintaining inspection and oversight by developing protocols to enable inspections  to continue, including, where possible, on-site inspections;
  • improving collection of data about deaths of workers in the adult social care sector;
  • establishing mandatory end-of-life training for relevant health and social care workers;  and
  • recognising and supporting the social care workforce in England through the  introduction of a voluntary register.

A full list of the Inquiry’s recommendations is included in Appendix 3 of the full report. The  Chair expects that all recommendations are acted upon and implemented. The Inquiry will  monitor the implementation of the recommendations during its lifetime.  

To find out more or to download a copy of the full Module 6 Report or other accessible  formats, visit: https://covid19.public-inquiry.uk/reports.

 

  1. Including care funded by the public and care paid for privately by the person or family arranging it. The type of care includes help
    with personal tasks and nursing care.